CEOE President Antonio Garamendi highlighted the importance of physical, digital and human infrastructures in the post-Covid stage, during the CAF 2020 virtual conference, held under the slogan “Europe-Latin America Relations, an alliance for economic recovery ”. At the event, inaugurated by the executive president of CAF, Luis Carranza and the Secretary of State for Economy and Business Support of Spain, Ana de la Cueva, prominent authorities and senior representatives of institutions, business organizations and companies from both regions participated . The meeting, organized by CAF, in collaboration with CEOE and Casa de América, was divided into two panels, which addressed, on the one hand, the bi-regional vision for economic recovery after the Covid-19 pandemic; and on the other, investment in physical and digital infrastructure as an engine for recovery in the Region.
The Ibero-American Secretary General, Rebeca Grynspan; the Ministers of Economy and Finance of Uruguay, Azucena Arbeleche, and of Ecuador, Mauricio Pozo; the Secretary of State for the Economy and Business Support of Spain, Ana de la Cueva; the European Commissioner for International Associations; Jutta Urpilainen; the executive president of CAF, Luis Carranza; European representative of the Bank, José Antonio García Belaunde; CAF's vice president of Infrastructure, Antonio Silveira; the Vice President of the European Investment Bank (EIB), Emma Navarro; the general director of CEOE Internacional and permanent secretary of CEIB, Narciso Casado; the executive director of ProPanamá, Carmen Gisela Vergara; the general director of Casa de América, Antonio Pérez-Hernández; Alstom's Senior Vice President of Public Affairs, Philippe Delleur; the CEO of Infrastructures of Acciona; Luis Castilla; and the correspondent for the International Economy of El País, Alicia González.
Infrastructures, training, public-private collaboration and sustainability
CEOE president, Antonio Garamendi, highlighted in his speech the importance of physical and digital infrastructure; but, above all, the best infrastructures that a country has, which are people and social dialogue. For the future of Latin America in the post-Covid era, he opted for unity of action, market freedom, multilateralism and public-private collaboration. He also assured that "digitization is globalization and needs to be accompanied by both innovation and training, both fundamental factors to achieve the goals that we set". Another priority, which will become a milestone of the 21st century, he stressed, is sustainability, which had its origin in energy and the circular economy; and that it will also depend on another indispensable element, industry, which is the engine that drives the rest of the economy. These challenges that Latin America has to face, he pointed out, should also be seen as opportunities to face economic recovery, "they are not challenges for a few, but for everyone as a whole, so we must overcome them together." For this reason, he added, to advance in these areas, CAF's work is key, especially to provide support to SMEs, which are the nucleus of economies; and assured that the Development Bank of Latin America has been a strategic partner of the Council of Ibero-American Entrepreneurs (CEIB) and CEOE for years.
Garamendi made a series of recommendations, as a roadmap to follow, to achieve progress in Latin America. It opted for legal security, to generate credibility and attract investment; by consensus and social dialogue, to reach agreements; for a more flexible regulatory framework adapted to changes; and for public-private collaboration, to improve efficiency and quality in the provision of public services, both in the field of education and health, and in infrastructure. Likewise, it considered essential the conservation of the productive fabric, through measures that are already working, such as guarantee lines or ERTEs; reindustrialization to generate quality and better paid employment; innovation and digitization of the productive fabric, of SMEs and public administrations; and equal opportunities and inclusive growth, through training and education. "This game we are going to win together, but we have to play game by game," he said.
Europe, a strategic partner
CAF's executive president, Luis Carranza, highlighted the need to forge strategic alliances with the European Union. In this sense, he highlighted the excellent relations that the Bank has maintained with Spain for more than 18 years, not only in the intense public-private collaboration that it maintains in the field of infrastructure, but also because of the support that has been channeled in the Region through different instruments in sectors such as innovation, water, agribusiness, and the common challenge they share to help SMEs and to develop a true industrial framework that allows establishing a regional value chain.
The Secretary of State for the Economy and Business Support of Spain, Ana de la Cueva, advocated promoting the growth of a sustainable economy in Latin America, which will not be possible without infrastructure as a backbone. To make this possible, "it is essential to strengthen multilateralism if we want to get out of the crisis." He also highlighted the role of banks to mobilize unprecedented resources that can help countries, and the importance of combining efforts from the public and private sectors to come out of this situation together. He also stressed the need for more effective regional and bilateral cooperation. "A global crisis requires global responses," he said.
Towards economic recovery after the pandemic: a bi-regional vision
The Ibero-American Secretary General, Rebeca Grynspan, spoke in the first panel of the day, moderated by the correspondent for the International Economy of El País, Alicia González. During the same, he assured that the pre-Covid structural conditions have interacted with the pandemic, and have accentuated the pre-existing gaps. He also considered that the way out of this crisis will be uneven depending on the regions and, in the case of Latin America, it cannot get out of this delicate situation alone, it will need the help of multilateral financial organizations and urged the G20 to demonstrate in favor of the Region. Europe has to be a fundamental partner to help Latin America emerge from this crisis, since, lacking the necessary tools, its recovery will be slower.
The Ministers of Economy and Finance of Ecuador, Mauricio Pozo and of Uruguay, Azucena Arbeleche; as well as the Vice President of the European Investment Bank (EIB), Emma Navarro, highlighted that Latin America will not be able to face the recovery in the Region without the support of the international community and financial organizations. "The role of the multilateral and cooperation is crucial to advance in the context of the pandemic," they stressed.
Investment in physical and digital infrastructure, engine for economic recovery
The permanent secretary of CEIB and general director of CEOE Internacional, Narciso Casado, presented the second panel of the day on the importance of physical and digital infrastructures, since they are the engine of recovery in the Region. In this sense, he assured that infrastructures are a dynamic element of economic growth, through the improvement of productivity and as a consolidation of social development, through the reduction of poverty and the promotion of the middle class. "In Latin America there is a great need for investment that allows us to promote equity, the development of city environments, social and educational development and institutional development," he said. The concept of physical infrastructure as such, he reported, emerged at the last Ibero-American Summit of Heads of State and Government, which was held in La Antigua, Guatemala, in 2018, and in which it was recognized that transportation infrastructure in Latin America it showed a general lag in relation to current and future needs, especially when compared to other regions with similar incomes. Development in Latin America, in his opinion, is strongly affected by the lack of investment in infrastructure, and therefore, the efforts made in this regard by governments and multilateral financing organizations will be fundamental especially in the post-Covid stage.
With regard to innovation and digital transformation, he assured that both factors are essential to face the recovery, physical infrastructures are not enough. Casado stressed that digitization is not an option, but absolutely necessary and has come to stay. In addition, he pointed out, it facilitates opportunities for interaction, reinvention of systems, work protocols and professional relationships. "Latin America has a huge opportunity in digital transformation to improve its productivity, this being one of the great challenges for companies in the Region," he insisted. On the other hand, he opted for an inclusive digital transformation, having access to technology is key to addressing production gaps. Entrepreneurship, education and innovation are three indisputable pillars to tackle the challenge of transformation, to which should be added the ability to collaborate; and the interrelation between investment, innovation and productivity is the most appropriate formula for Ibero-American development, he concluded.
Sustainable planning and infrastructure
CAF's Vice President of Infrastructure, Antonio Silveira, assured that, in the face of economic recovery through infrastructures, it must be analyzed strategically, seeing the actions that are necessary in the short term and developing adequate planning and a plan of long-term sustained financing. Simple schemes are needed that can mobilize the population and generate income immediately. It would be necessary to carry out, he explained, maintenance programs, rapid execution, integrated mobility projects, and generate the digital capacity that passes through the infrastructure and human capital. In this sense, he assured that, according to the IMF, 40,000 jobs are created for every 1,000 million dollars.
The executive director of ProPanamá, for her part, reported on the projects that are being carried out in the area, and reported that Central America is betting on the construction of roads, trains, water treatment plants or power plants. The region contemplates the development of infrastructure, he stressed, not only in the short term, but also looking to the future, in order for it to influence the improvement of competitiveness and productivity at the regional level. This area is one of the most important for the government of Panama, he explained, and a national plan has been developed that focuses on two pillars: construction and attraction of foreign direct investment. The infrastructure sector is essential to promote trade and tourism, which have been hit hard by the pandemic, he said.
ACCIONA's CEO of Infrastructure, Luis Castilla, in turn, recommended not to paralyze the activities of execution and maintenance of infrastructure, since they will be essential for the speed of return in society. After the initial shock, he said, infrastructure projects have shown that they are capable of living with the pandemic, as long as there is good collaboration between the public and private sectors, workers are protected, and activity can be maintained. Well-organized activities can complement each other, he added. Likewise, he urged those present to make a deep reflection on the contractual models that we have at the moment, since the majority started with legal models from the 20th century, even from the 19th century. "For faster returns, you need faster and more flexible environments so that everything works better," he said. In addition, the planning and development of sustainable infrastructures are essential for exiting the crisis, he concluded.
Alstom's Vice President of Public Affairs, Phillippe Delleur, was convinced that the crisis has presented a great opportunity to be optimistic, thanks to the money that has been allocated to recovery plans, development banks have proven to have a very important role . "This is a fantastic time to accelerate sustainability, especially in the mobility sector," he said. Delleur also opted for supporting itself with technology that comes from Latin America, through projects that encompass technology, incorporating it in the way of bidding for projects. "Continuity is key to the success of projects," he stressed. In this sense, he stressed the importance of mobility, transport is arriving very late and has to accelerate. Another priority factor to take into account, he insisted, is legal security for investments, favorable conditions must be generated for trade and investment. To do this, he advocated following international legal frameworks, maintaining continuity in projects, promoting green technologies and giving these technologies an advantage.
Human infrastructure and social dialogue
To conclude this last panel, the permanent secretary of CEIB, Narciso Casado, highlighted the importance of other infrastructures such as human infrastructure, which is one that is oriented towards people, citizens, and especially towards young people, who are the future of Ibero-America, in addition to being the best-trained generation we have ever had, he considered. In this sense, he highlighted training, education and, above all, the retention of talent. And another of the infrastructures that he mentioned, and to which the CEOE president, Antonio Garamendi, already referred, is social dialogue, which constitutes the best infrastructure in a country.
By way of closing, the CAF representative in Europe, José Antonio García Belaunde, agreed with other speakers by pointing out that the effects of Covid are being suffered by all of us, and the gains of these years in Latin America can turn into losses. For this reason, he assured that, in order to move forward and not slow down progress, integration and inclusion must be promoted, and this cannot be achieved without the necessary development of infrastructures, not only physical ones, but also digital ones. Belaunde mentioned that the Bank has numerous projects planned to launch in the Region, but they cannot be carried out without the unconditional support of Europe.